Fanatic Fans Updates
 
IPL Review 2010 Phase 2 results
Anisha @ RCB , 13 May 2010
42 Comments

And with a snap of the finger, another 5 days pass by. Its end of phase 2 and time to announce the Phase 2 winners!

The winnersssss areeeeeeeeeee ............................

IPL Review Phase II Winner is Sachin Kodagali
Read his review here
Judge’s note: You took the cake! Precise, apt and good skills. Pen is mightier than the sword…err the bat in this case!

IPL Review Phase II First Runner Up is Jagadish Tulagapu
Read his review here
Judge’s note: Very neat one. Impressed with your style of straight talk.

IPL Review Phase II Second Runner Up is Faruk Hosain
Read his review here
Judge’s note: You gave a new horizon to look through. Very good take on IPL.



A few other reviews that had the judge impressed -

Shobha Modak - Read her review
Judge’s note: You nearly won one prize! Loved the spirit and the writing off-course!

Varun Hotanakatte - Read his review
Judge’s note: I am beginning to be a fan of yours. Way to go!

______________________

Congratulations to all the winners. Watch out for my mail to claim your prizes!! Cheers!!!
42 Comments
Post a comment
Notify me of follow-up comments?
Latest comments
Still i havent received a mail for the 2nd phase review winners ...
Sachinbengaluru on 17 May 2010, 11:55 AM
FUCK MAN
FRANKLEANO on 16 May 2010, 09:03 PM
hi, anisha
suhass on 14 May 2010, 08:52 PM
Will reply to the mail and give the address on monday,Thanks ...
Sachinbengaluru on 14 May 2010, 08:29 PM
Nidhi : I have not yet got the mail, sorry if i am hurrying things. If i see the mail before 8:45 today i will reply else i will post the address here
Sachinbengaluru on 14 May 2010, 07:39 PM
p.s. sorry i've been posting as both nidhi@rcb and moderator today... i'm moderating the IPL Review Phase 3 entries :P
moderator on 14 May 2010, 06:57 PM
@Sachin thanks for notifying me. I'll try to have the email sent out right now... prizes will be dispatched middle of next week.

enjoy your weekend!
moderator on 14 May 2010, 06:56 PM
Nidhi - I have not yet got a mail from you on how to claim prizes. I will be out of station this weekend and will reply back to your mail on Monday.

Have a nice weekend.
Sachinbengaluru on 14 May 2010, 06:41 PM
Justification of why we picked Faruk's review, and a surprise twist at this post... http://www.royalchallengers.com/blog/goof-ups-aside-new-winner-declared
nidhi@RCB on 14 May 2010, 12:06 PM
Cheers, Anisha .... this was probably the second most-heated post this IPL, after all the anti-Kallis posts during IPL-3.
Prometheus on 14 May 2010, 11:50 AM
Your comments are all valid. Have just discussed with the judges and we'll be making an announcement in ... 10-15 minutes (about how long it'll take me to write up the blog post..)

and Prometheus, thanks for clarifying ;) sorry about the goof up. I've updated the post
nidhi@RCB on 14 May 2010, 11:45 AM
congrats winners!!!!!!
srishti-gajare on 14 May 2010, 10:58 AM
i did not take part in review competition,i believed i didnt have the quality,,bt nw i think i am better than selected winners in phase2;
iam confused nw,,in phase 3
should we write about RCB or our players,or players of other teams like yuvi,sangakkara,ishant,goni........,who had nothing to do with our sucess,,,JUDGES please explain the criteria of ur selection
haree71 on 14 May 2010, 09:29 AM
Congratulation winners!

I am sure Anisha will come up with sort of explaination soon. Looks like Faruk is rewarded for thinking 'out of the box'. But the problem is noone else knew it was allowed and they were all boxing in the box...It also looks like the "collective reviews" were preferred over the "match by match" review (Sachin's was an exception).
Well, we can only guess till we get some explanation from the judges.

Such contests are always subjective and we can all afford to be judges. I didnot participate in the contest and to my un-biased eyes, Prometheus's (Varun) review was the best.
harsha-vardhan on 14 May 2010, 08:22 AM
STILL NO COMMENT FRM ADMIN OR FRM JUDGE???????
MrNiceguy on 14 May 2010, 08:03 AM
congo guys...
i like this statement from varun..

But this time, Sreesanth must have silently giggled to himself...it wasn't him but Brett Lee who's confidence got punctured (25 runs in the 17th). :)
Pun33t on 13 May 2010, 10:36 PM
On the right side of the IPL contest page a list of our matches is there but Faruk neither wrote about RCB nor about the IPL matches. His review was basically about the players of all the teams which didn't reach the semis whom we don't really care about. If I knew this was allowed, I would have written about Kings XI and made fun of them. Nonetheless I still have a chance to make fun of Deccan Chargers in Phase 3.
ashetty21 on 13 May 2010, 09:11 PM
Congrats Winners! Not undermining the efforts of the 2nd runner up but the flak that his selection in the top 3 has received, is valid.
disha-shetty on 13 May 2010, 08:17 PM
Congrats to all the winners.Special thanks to anisha for keeping RCB fans going even after end of the IPL Season.

I am excited to participate in the review contest
RCBInKannada on 13 May 2010, 07:44 PM
Winning or losing a competition, is a part of the game, however, the playing field should be level for all.

While writing the reviews, one thought that the focus has to be on quality, analysis and relevance. However, the choice of winners tells something else.
Wizardprince on 13 May 2010, 07:37 PM
Congrats all winners sad i missed out winning another competition will come back with the 3rd review will try ma best out der to win . Just had a small doubt abt the II runner up i mean isn't this competition abt the second phase of the rcb season ??? well if it isn't ok he deserves it anyways pls do look into it cos we need to stick to the topic to avoid complaints and criticism hoping u guys would do a much better job in tht thnkin u will come back with a much better review next time :)
PrinceDravid on 13 May 2010, 07:11 PM
Looks like some people has not written any review they just read the reviews and comments here. As far as popular reviews go i think if i have 100 friends in this RCB website and even though my review is poor they will vote that review. So at the end it should be both popular reviews and good writing that should be considered for the prizes.

All said i think Varun and Sheffins reviews were also good.
shwethsach on 13 May 2010, 06:54 PM
Dear soleiletchiots: u got da point which the organizers didn't lets woke them up
MrNiceguy on 13 May 2010, 06:52 PM
'IPL Review is a contest of RC's performance post IPL 2010 amongst RC fans! You can talk about the highs and lows of RC this season. You can be our best or worst critic! Talk about the team's performances, strategy, dropped catches etc.'

Even I am miffed at the selection of the second runner up and I am not even participating in the contest so I have no agenda here. The person's review had nothing do do with our team. I agree with what others have wriiten, there are more deserving candidates.
soleiletchiots on 13 May 2010, 06:50 PM
Congrats all the winners, you all deserved it. I also wrote a nice review and will continue trying hard to win in the III phase.
shwethsach on 13 May 2010, 06:46 PM
Ah thaught d judges would like some review which is of a person's own n not dat of a person sitting opening ten site n writing...but who know who r judging us...congrats winners what else could i say now... :(
Manish-Bansal on 13 May 2010, 06:35 PM
Congrats Sachin and Faruk!!
@ Thanks Anisha!!
jackky on 13 May 2010, 06:31 PM
Thanks Anisha and all the judges for selecting me as the winner. Really happy to be part of this wonderful site and participating all the contests.

Regards,
Sachin
Sachinbengaluru on 13 May 2010, 06:20 PM
@prometheus,,anisha is a doing a gr8 job,keeping this site so active even after the ipl,,lets b grateful for her efforts
but for the people who have selected winners,,,YOU people have made a mess,,shocking selection!!!truely unfair for we fans
its not becoz i didnt win,phase 1,,best 3 were selected
but now it hurts!!! @prometheus
sheffin on 13 May 2010, 06:16 PM
dear Prometheus: this contest is for analysis of team rcb performance in ipl divided into 3 phase.And not about individual players agenda. judges should know the rules of the contest before declaring the winner they can't break rules as they like. it hurts as a rcb fans
MrNiceguy on 13 May 2010, 05:55 PM
@Sheffin...Liked your review, man. Good Stuff!! But let's not be sore losers here. The kind of insight you put into your review, I'm pretty sure you'll come up trumps in IPL-Phase III, so don't lose heart. And it's pointless screaming at Anisha. From what I've heard, it's a bunch of people who decide the winners and not Anisha alone. So i think it's unfair to point fingers at her. Looking forward to your Phase-III review, dude!!!
Prometheus on 13 May 2010, 05:50 PM
MY REVIEW WAS FAR BETTER THAN 2ND RUNNER UP VIEW MY REVIEW @ http://www.royalchallengers.com/ipl-2010-review/MrNiceguy
MrNiceguy on 13 May 2010, 05:47 PM
not only the 2nd runnerup
i can find atleast 10 reviews,which was far better than top 3,,i am sure u people will also agree
why r u keeping a most popular column if u r not considering that
deeply dissappointed as a true RCB fan,,

reselect the winners
haree71 on 13 May 2010, 05:46 PM
i took part in all the contest of this site,won a jersey through MGM
wrote both the reviews,
1st review,i truely believe all 3 were deserving,,,
2nd review,,horrible selection
hey anisha,,please read my review
http://www.royalchallengers.com/ipl-2010-review/sheffin
please explain why was it bad compared to your top 3;;;;
sheffin on 13 May 2010, 05:36 PM
I THINK THE CONTEST IS GOING ON TO ANALYSIS THE PERFORMANCE OF TEAM RCB IN IPL 3 AND NOT ABOUT PLAYERS OF OTHER TEAMS. JUDGES AND ADMIN SHOULD CLARIFY TO OTHER WHY THEY R RUNING THE CONTEST BREAKING UR OWN RULES.......
2ND RUNNER UP REVIEW IS NO WHERE COMES TO THIS CONTEST ..... A FLOP DECISION
MrNiceguy on 13 May 2010, 05:35 PM
thats what i also told varun,his review had nothing to do with RCB,thus should not have been considered at all,,
fairly i think there were many other reviews better than the top 3 selected ones
this is truely unfair for us,,
sheffin on 13 May 2010, 05:29 PM
Don't mean to be a spoil sport but to be honest, I'm a little surprised at the selection of the 3rd winner. I couldn't see anything related to RCB in it. It was a general "why IPL players flopped" write up!!
Prometheus on 13 May 2010, 05:16 PM
shocking!!!!
i have read many reviews,i am sure,there were altleast 10-15 reviwes better than the winning ones
@anisha,,,,all the 3 reviews lacked good analysis of 7 RCB matches,,2nd runnerup has mentioned nothing about RCB,,,yoi have to explainnn ur selection
truely UNFAIR to others
haree71 on 13 May 2010, 05:09 PM
deeply disappointed with our selecton of winners
this contest is to review the rcb's performance ,
2nd runner up faruk hosain has mentioned nothing about RCB'S performance;or any of its players,,he talked about yuvraj,warner,ishant those players have nothing to do with our performance
Varun Hotanakatte was far far better than first 3 winners;
my review i believe was better than the winners
http://www.royalchallengers.com/ipl-2010-review/sheffin
not only myne there were many,,go look at popular reviews,,i bet u can find better ones than the picked ones
sheffin on 13 May 2010, 04:40 PM
And one quick pointer on a lighter note .... I very much happen to be a male ... so please read the words above as "Read HIS review" :)
Prometheus on 13 May 2010, 04:30 PM
Congratulations lady and gents!! :) Good stuff from all. It's such a warm feeling to know how passionate and involved everyone is with RCB. We are one heck of a community!!!!
Prometheus on 13 May 2010, 04:26 PM
subscribe to rss
ABOUT THE
COMMUNITY MANAGERS
Nidhi@RCB,Chintan@RCB and Foram@RCB are the community managers of the fan club. They cover site updates, upcoming contests and what's going on in the Fan Club. They also carry messages back and forth between Fans and the club management.

 

Subscribe to the RSS to stay updated on latest activities.

 

For the latest on the pitch, check out the News section. For the latest blog posts from the Fanatic Fans, head to the Fan Club.

 

Questions? Concerns? Email community@royalchallengers.com
Archives