| Join Now | Login

Fan Club> Debates

02-Dec to 14-Dec

Is it unfair to drop players from the National squad without giving them a game?

Verdict

nidhi at rcb

It is unfair to drop players from the National squad without giving them a game. Bench strength cannot be assessed unless it is tested. Players are kept from appearing for their domestic teams in that time, without playing experience, their time is wasted. They should be retained in the team until they get a chance to prove their credentials on the big stage.

53.33 % Defend

46.67 % Attack

Monish Moorthy

Foram Gosrani

“ Being named for the Test squad is of no use unless there is a policy which ensures that every one plays atleast one game ”

“ Players who have been dropped without a game should not take it personally and instead focus in a team's balance. ”

Monish Moorthy: Aravind was dropped for the WI ODIs without playing a single game against England. What wrong did he do to find himself out of the squad? Similarly is the case of Ajinkya Rahane, a member of the Test squad against the Windies: he chose to play for his state team in Ranji knowing that he wouldn't get an immediate chance in the playing 11.

Foram Gosrani: It's not unfair if the Team has found the perfect balance. 15 member squads are chosen to give the Captain options for different pitches, conditions. If the players who got a game ahead of Aravind, who do the exact same job as Aravind have done a good enough job then the captain should go ahead with those players. He cannot drop them because they have proven themselves.

For

4 Opinions

i think every player should be given an extra chance

10 Dec 2011

chiruchetu

if at all they don get a game wat's d use of picking dem n warming d ###????? instead dey could b in touch by playing atleat d domestic circuit..

09 Dec 2011

sandeep28may

yes virat kohli should open the inning with chris gayle because this will provide stability to the team as chris is a great strokeplayer and virat can give good support as he is a sensible one and has a variety of strokes

09 Dec 2011

attakers

my opinion is every 15 players named in squad should get the chance

07 Dec 2011

Against

5 Opinions

Sand007

Such players must always taken forward to the next tour......

12 Dec 2011

donz

i feel the player's must know the conditions first and take more time to get them self's in the playing 11!!!and when they are fully fit then they can perform extremely well!

09 Dec 2011

10087

s she is right........

09 Dec 2011

balredz

in my point its right to balance the teams the opposite is strong and at that we wan use the crct persons to replace who has experienced and otherwise i support monish and every gets the chance they has wait then only they get much intrest in the game and can perform gud in the game

08 Dec 2011

udds

There are many players like Aravind, and seniors like agarkar and kaif has to be given a chance in single series so that we can have more ### strength and options to explore wen other players are injured

03 Dec 2011

Suggest a topic

Drop in your suggestion for the next debate

Click Here

PLEASE CONFIRM!

OR

OR

Post your opinion

Fan Club

Verdict