Hello,

Victoria Bush Rangers, Guyana or the Lions we played are all local state teams, while teams from IPL are not,,,, it has 4 foreign players and not to mention players from all across India. 

So in last match only 4 players ( Dravid, Vinay, Uthappa & Manish ) still play for karnataka Ranji team, is it fair competition??

Pavan

Pavan-Kumar1 - 23 September 2010 02:31 AM

Hello,

Victoria Bush Rangers, Guyana or the Lions we played are all local state teams, while teams from IPL are not,,,, it has 4 foreign players and not to mention players from all across India. 

So in last match only 4 players ( Dravid, Vinay, Uthappa & Manish ) still play for karnataka Ranji team, is it fair competition??

Pavan

what do u mean by fair team…. we have more international players than they do….. and its not who is the state team or who is not… they are the winners of their respective t20 tournaments in their country.. so they are qualified for the tournament. they don’t have a big stage like our ipl ..... i totally think its fair and square. i even feel we have a little advantage over them

@ganesh- we got the finance to retain big international stars! thts a big plus. now if it was local players just playing, then its more like a international t20 championship. i like the CL format. its vry competitive. i gues 3 insted of 4 international players during CL is better

there’s nothing abt fair .....look they may be state teams but they have players from different states and sometimes from different countries as well…...ipl is a bit more exposed outside so we have a bit more reknowned cricketeres in our side…..and the format of the clt20 is just to bring in champions of all leagues to fight for the trophy and it’s an amazin tourney…

hey remember that even they had the services of foreign players for the domestic tourney..for instance, its unfortunate that all of ross’s teams qualified, if RCB hadn’t he wouldve played for victoria or stags..