Do you think we need to swap Dirk Nannes with Pune Warriors India for Alfonso Thomas or Wayne Parnell?
Moreover we should try for Vinay in the auction.
What do you think guys?

trading is over i guess

I believe still there is a shorter trading window after the auction.

ya there is a tranfer window

karthik-shetty4 - 23 January 2012 07:56 AM

Do you think we need to swap Dirk Nannes with Pune Warriors India for Alfonso Thomas or Wayne Parnell?
Moreover we should try for Vinay in the auction.
What do you think guys?

Very difficult topic to make decision.

Wt abt swapin dilshan for van der marve r jp duminy, as v need to strengthn our collapsin middle order?

Wt abt swapin tiwary for uthappa?

but i think trading is not required for rcb now. if rcb get vinay ,rp,akhil in auction then we have lot of bowling option.
1)zaheer
2)vattori
3)vinay
4)RP
5)akhil
6)arvind
7)mithun
8)nannes
9)mcdonald

and another reason is 4 place for foreign players is already confirmed
1)vettori- skipper- he is there in team for all matches
2)gayle- he is there in team for all matches.
3)ab-wicket keeper- exellent wicket keeper and explosive batsman
4)dilshan- he is available for only some matches.
5)mcdonald- allrounder- i think he play every game when dilshan is not available
6)Nannes- cal also get some chance

i think there is no chance for other foreign players.

niranjan1nnn - 23 January 2012 08:32 AM

karthik-shetty4 - 23 January 2012 07:56 AM

Do you think we need to swap Dirk Nannes with Pune Warriors India for Alfonso Thomas or Wayne Parnell?
Moreover we should try for Vinay in the auction.
What do you think guys?

Very difficult topic to make decision.

Wt abt swapin dilshan for van der marve r jp duminy, as v need to strengthn our collapsin middle order?

Wt abt swapin tiwary for uthappa?

swaping uttappa is impossible because pwi not allow it.
swaping dilshan is not a bad idea. it is good if we get van der marve or jp duminy.
both are explosive batsman who can play in any position and can bowl full 4 over.
ya rcb can try this

v can release Johan van der Wath or Drik Nannes if possible both n can go for Vernon Philander or
Lonwabo Tsotsobe in d acutions…. Hope v can make dis n sign Vernon Philander in d acutions….

Wat say guys???

N i think its better if dilshan plays in middle order. Den no need of transfer. He has d experience of playin in d middle ordr n rescuein d team

niranjan1nnn - 23 January 2012 08:50 AM

N i think its better if dilshan plays in middle order. Den no need of transfer. He has d experience of playin in d middle ordr n rescuein d team

ya i agree with u. if dilshan available then he should play in middle order.
1)gayle
2)agarwal
3)kohli
4)ab
5)dilshan/mcdonald’
6)tiwari
7)vettori
8)akhil
9)vinay
10)zaheer
11)syed/arvind

Try with MCdonald in d middle order…. he is a good allrounder n can be handy with d ball…. Ma 4 overseas player in d playing 11 would be Gayle, Vettori, ABD, McDonald….

Neil003 - 23 January 2012 09:16 AM

Try with MCdonald in d middle order…. he is a good allrounder n can be handy with d ball…. Ma 4 overseas player in d playing 11 would be Gayle, Vettori, ABD, McDonald….

Bt until dilshan is present, he wil play al d matches, bcoz he is a international reputed playr den mcdonald.

karthik-shetty4 - 23 January 2012 07:56 AM

Do you think we need to swap Dirk Nannes with Pune Warriors India for Alfonso Thomas or Wayne Parnell?
Moreover we should try for Vinay in the auction.
What do you think guys?

Alfonso Thomas, cause he is much talented than Nannes, and he is also a great captain for Somerset…He has also been doing good in Adelaide Strikers too…OMG!! I thought he was born in England…and came to know now that hes from SA. he is 34 Years and Parnell is 22.  But Thomas is more experienced.
I wish Johan Botha to swap for Nannes, but RR wont leave him.

@karthik-shetty…Meanwhile, whom do you think dude?

thomas for nannes would be a good deal but the question remains whether pune would release him cos he was brilliant for them last year he along with rahul sharma were the only 2 bright spots so it wont be that easy , and also we should release van der wath and even pomers i still dont understand van der wath’s signing and go for a better bowler like tsotsobe or fidel or even russel wont be a bad buy in the auction. what say?

Better to go for the death over bowlers..as we concede a lot of runs in those..

Brett Lee would be a grt swap signing as he is acquainted in these overs and has a very good yorker with fearsome pace..

Philander and Tsotsobe will be better recruits if they are available..

thomas to nannes is a gud deal, but i doubt it will work. we shud try for uthappa by giving dilshan, and can try for some player in the auction, maybe bopara o voges

I agree with you Dilshan is being wasted..also agree that we should try and go for Siddle or Philander..Van der Wath would harldy get a game

niranjan1nnn - 23 January 2012 09:45 AM

Neil003 - 23 January 2012 09:16 AM

Try with MCdonald in d middle order…. he is a good allrounder n can be handy with d ball…. Ma 4 overseas player in d playing 11 would be Gayle, Vettori, ABD, McDonald….

Bt until dilshan is present, he wil play al d matches, bcoz he is a international reputed playr den mcdonald.

ya i agree. if dilshan is present then he should play

RoyalShaan - 25 January 2012 07:28 AM

I agree with you Dilshan is being wasted..also agree that we should try and go for Siddle or Philander..Van der Wath would harldy get a game

no i am not agree with you. dilshan is currently in exeelent form and we can use him to bowl his spin during power play. he already proved he can play good in powerplay. but i think he should play in middle order with tiwari. he already have experiance in plying middle order and lift team .